(This article is a sort-of sequel to my previous piece, The End of Celebrity Sex, which provides further context to the issues I explore below.)
One of the more surprising conversations of my life happened when I met a man in his mid twenties who claimed to have had a nice childhood.
The man and I were discussing a mutual acquaintance, who had had a particularly tough time growing up, and I said:
"I mean, I know nobody had it perfect, and I'm sure you had difficulties yourself... "
He thought for a moment, shrugged, and said:
"No, not really."
I was thrown.
"What do you mean, 'not really'?"
"I mean, I didn't really have difficulties growing up. Everything was pretty much fine."
I eyed him suspiciously.
"'Fine'?"
"Yes, fine."
"Your parents stayed together and were happy?"
"Yep."
"You got on with your siblings?"
"Uh-huh."
"You weren't bullied at school?"
"No."
I considered this information deeply.
"You mean to tell me that your childhood was actually... happy?"
"Yeah. Isn't that normal?"
"Er, no," I sighed. "It's not. It's really not."
At least, it's not any more, and hasn't been for at least three or four decades, a fact I had confirmed to me when I studied in the USA, and my composition teacher was a woman in her seventies who had been teaching since 1965.
She told me that, every year since she'd begun teaching, one of the first assignments she set her students was to write an essay about something significant that had happened to them during their childhood.
When she began her career, students would typically submit pieces about such things as the arrival of a new baby sibling, a memorable family vacation, or a special sporting or academic achievement. Almost all of the essays relayed an experience that was memorable because it was positive.
As the decades went on, things began to change. The themes of the essays began to turn darker, and, she said, by the time of the turn of the century, most of the submissions had become about events that were memorable because they were traumatic and sad.
The day Dad left. The awful things a stepparent did. The severely autistic sibling.
By the time I was studying with her in 2013, she said things had become so bad, she almost dreaded setting the assignment at all.
Long-term psychological data and happiness surveys largely support her experience, showing a progressive decline in childhood mental health since the mid-20th century, alongside a sharp drop in overall youth life satisfaction.
Meanwhile, many so called 'ACE's - adverse childhood experiences, known to cause lasting harm - have steadily increased since the 1960s, including sustained verbal abuse, parental separation and divorce, parental substance misuse, and parental incarceration.
Examining modern childhoods, and the consequences of ACEs throughout a lifetime, a recent study found:
"Adverse childhood experiences (ACEs), which include abuse, neglect, and family dysfunction, are strongly associated with adverse physical and mental health outcomes, such as mental illness, substance use, chronic diseases, and obesity.1 Prolonged exposure to ACEs, coupled with a lack of supportive caregivers and/or interventions, can lead to toxic stress and potentially disrupt brain development.2 Children experiencing ACEs may also encounter cognitive, social, and emotional challenges. These challenges often result in the adoption of risky health behaviors, such as early smoking and substance misuse,3,4,5 thereby exacerbating personal health issues and increasing the risk of premature death.6,7,8 Furthermore, the impact of ACEs extends beyond personal health and well-being; they can affect subsequent generations9,10 and impose significant economic costs on local communities and even on the national scale."
Dramatic social shifts that have taken place - or rather, that have been engineered to take place - since the 1960s mean that, for an ever-increasing number of children, childhood is not a safe place, but a psychological battleground, where their sense of security and stability is continually undermined.
How has society been taught to respond to this sharp shift?
By professing that:
"Children are so resilient!"
The broken homes, the mental illness, the intoxicated or incarcerated parents, we need not worry very much about these things, since children possess great inner "resilience". They can cope just fine with all manner of disruptions, stressors, and traumas because...
Children are adults.
That is the real message. To suggest that a person possesses the emotional resources and psychological strength to appropriately manage severe life challenges - such as family breakdown, abuse, and mental illness - is to suggest that a person is an adult, because actual children, by definition, cannot do this. Actual children do not possess the requisite psychological tools to independently manage severe life stress: that is the job of adults. It is the job of adults to help children manage it if it is unavoidable, and to shield them from it where it is possible.
But if children are seen as capable of managing these things alone, then that can only be because children are adults - and there is a sturdy body of evidence to show, increasingly, that is how children have been treated in modern culture. Millions of children have been 'parentified', whereby the nominal adults around them have inverted traditional roles.
The adult becomes the child - whose desires, emotional issues, and psychological problems must come first - and the child becomes the adult - who must manage, adapt to, and deal with whatever the adult requires, forfeiting the right to be parented, nurtured, and safeguarded themselves.
That children are adults whose parents are not responsible for safeguarding them has even been codified into law, with the Gillick competency ruling.
This ruling enables children as young as 12, and potentially even younger than that, to make their own life-altering decisions about medical treatment, including vaccinations, and to seek contraception and abortion without parental knowledge or consent.
So, children are adults. The law effectively says so.
According to modernity and the New Morality, it is not until they are eighteen that they actually become children.
Then we ought worry desperately about them. Then they become tremendously fragile and vulnerable and at risk of harm, because someone a handful of years older than them might want to take them on a date.
At this point, we have to be so concerned about them that, according to The Guardian, if we see an eighteen-year-old walking down the street with a man who appears to be older than her, we ought immediately apprehend that man, and demand to know just what he thinks he is doing with this - to quote the publication's perfectly Orwellian doublespeak - "baby adult".
To encourage members of the public to intervene in other people's perfectly legal relationships - and "relationship" is not even defined here as some sort of enamoured display, but literally just walking down the road together - is a new degree of epic insanity, even for the much-mocked Grauniad. This is even more poignantly underlined given that the newspaper displays so little consideration for actual children facing very real dangers.
Here is a letter The Guardian published on "puberty blockers" being administered to underage children:
"The Gillick competence test is used in medical law to decide whether a child under the age of 16 is able to consent to their own treatment, without the need for parental permission or knowledge.
In the area of child and adolescent mental health, there is an increasing demand for help from very disturbed, anxious, and unhappy children feeling trapped inside the “wrong” body. Clinicians do not make hasty judgments and they bend over backwards to keep open communication with parents and engage children in long, comprehensive tests and counselling sessions before embarking on treatments. Sixteen is an arbitrary age because children mature at different rates."
So when it comes to profoundly chemically altering one's body and mind in a way that is often irreversible (and comes with huge risks), children should be free to decide for themselves, and the age they are is "arbitrary".
But when full legal adults of 18 feel like taking a stroll with another adult who happens to be a few years older than them, we should call the police and child protective services.
The Guardian goes on, in another article, to proudly proclaim that:
"Covid teams can vaccinate pupils against parents' wishes."
The week the covid vaccine became available to 12-15 year olds - therefore enabling children to go to vaccination centres without their parents to receive the injection - two boys aged 14 and 15 from the same school "died suddenly".
The covid vaccine is well known to cause a wide range of severe health problems, including death, but nevertheless, it is considered thoroughly acceptable to The Guardian - commendable, even - for children of 12 to receive it without their parents' knowledge.
Meanwhile, adult women of 22 who decide to go to a pop concert are apparently so vulnerable that they require constant chaperoning, lest they might - brace yourself - sit in a room with a man...
It was actual headline news in The Times that: "At 22 I was pursued by a pop star. I ended up in a bedroom with him".
If a 22-year-old woman decides to have a consensual encounter with a 30-something man, it's hardly headline news, but what is even more lunatic about this particular situation is that absolutely nothing happened between the 22-year-old woman and said man. They just talked. He made no sexual overtures towards her at all, and then she left.
Yet his simply existing in the same space as her was apparently such a mortal threat to her fragile vulnerability that she is still traumatised by it two decades later.
There is, obviously, not a shred of evidence anywhere that sitting in the same room as an older adult is in any way traumatic, let alone that it causes lasting trauma, but where it comes to events for which there is an avalanche of evidence to show they do cause lasting harm to (actual) children, the press is strangely sanguine.
Reporting on the epidemic of family breakdown and its effects on children, The Guardian reports that the main notable challenge of divorce is that "the kids' school clothes are always in the wrong house".
Commenting on her daughter, who is eleven, the journalist says:
"My daughter starts crying. She is incredibly stoic, these days, so her bursting into tears is more or less unheard of."
Of course, she would be "incredibly stoic", and superbly in control of her emotions, because children are adults.
The journalist confirms that is indeed her interpretation of her daughter, by stating: "On paper, I accept that [my daughter] is her own person, with her own personality. Deep down, I basically think we’re identical."
To repeat, her daughter is eleven, and, at the time of writing, the journalist, Zoe Williams, was 48.
Children being adults is also a trope we can observe in modern literature, where the phenomenon was explored in the Nick Hornby novel (and film), About A Boy. The story focuses on 12-year-old Marcus, and the assortment of extremely immature adults around him. There's Will, 36, who's never had a job; there's Clive, Marcus's 40-something dad, who thinks he's cool because he smokes weed and has a younger girlfriend; and finally, there's Fiona, Marcus's self-absorbed single mother, who sits in the kitchen every morning crying.
Marcus knows his mother is not physically ill, has enough money, and that nobody's died recently, so he is mystified as to what's wrong with her.
This means that Marcus, who is also being bullied at school - in his words, "having a shit time at school and a shit time at home" - is expected to function as the sole domestic support for an adult with serious mental health issues (his mother later tries to kill herself) whilst also looking after himself.
In other words, he has not only become his own parent, but his parent's parent, as well.
This parentification of young children, and forcing them into psychological support roles they are decades too young for, has become an increasingly common social phenomenon, which is why Nick Hornby wrote an (enormously popular) book about it.
It is made abundantly clear in About A Boy that the 'boy' of the title more refers to 36-year-old Will than it does Marcus, and there is a scene where Will - who is 24 years Marcus's senior - is horrified to be mistaken for his father. (Childless Will enters the narrative after posing as a single father so he can go to a single parents' group to try and pull women.)
There are millions of "Marcuses" in the world - pre-adolescent children cast into roles as carers, therapists, and parents to adults decades older than them - but the press cares very little about this kind of childhood damage and exploitation.
It cares far more about the "plight" of 17-year-olds who have had the vanishingly rare experience of being briefly romantically involved with a celebrity. This has probably only happened to about 0.01% or less of all teenagers who have ever lived, but nevertheless, we must now use it to make massive legislative changes that affect millions of people.
Meanwhile, whilst we are handwringing over the urgent moral emergency of contemplating whether 25-year-olds might theoretically have been damaged had 32-year-olds happened to notice them, the Labour Party is diligently working to lower the voting age to 16.
So, let's get this modern new approach to maturity and morality correct:
At 12, you can choose your gender, stop puberty, receive injections that might kill you, and abort your child, all without parental knowledge or consent.
At 16, you can cast a vote declaring how you think the country should be run.
At 18, you can take on enormous personal debt of up to £50,000 or more.
But it is not until you are 27 (at least) that you can walk down the street with a member of the opposite sex.
After all, given women in their earlier twenties can sometimes pass for teenagers, we'll have to put "walking down the street age" to at least the late twenties. You know, to protect the (18 and 19-year-old) kids.
The corollary of all this is that we have now genuinely come to the social point where the following statements are deeply revolutionary, even subversive:
Men are men, and can't be women.
Children are children, and can't be adults.
Adults are adults, and can't be children.
To return to the anecdote I shared at the beginning of this essay, it would be great if we could ensure more people had happy childhoods. But in order to do that, we first have to urgently define what 'childhood' actually is, when it begins, and crucially, when it ends.
Thanks for reading! This site is entirely reader-powered, with no paywalls, adverts, or wealthy corporate backers, making it truly independent. Your support is therefore crucial to ensuring this site's continued existence. If you'd like to make a contribution to help this site keep going, please consider...
1. Subscribing monthly via Patreon or Substack (where paid subscribers can comment on posts)
2. Making a one-off contribution via BuyMeACoffee
3. Contributing in either way via bank transfer to Nat West account number 30835984, sort code 54-10-27, account name FINCH MA (please use your email address as a reference if you'd like me to acknowledge receipt).
Your support is what allows this site to continue to exist and is enormously appreciated. Thank you.